top of page

MASHATILE PROTECTS THE PEOPLE

Mpho Dube
2 hours ago
4 min read

Punish Officials, Not The People: No More Withholding Money Meant For Poor Communities

By Mpho Dube, Editor-in-Chief

The Azanian | Truth. Fearless. Unfiltered.  

AZANIAFROCOMEDIA – The Catalyst of Impact

 

When Parliament pressed him, Deputy President Paul Mashatile did not hide behind Treasury rules. He stood up for the people.


In a powerful and compassionate performance in the National Assembly on Thursday, Mashatile made it clear that government will avoid withholding municipal equitable-share funds in future to force compliance, after National Treasury temporarily suspended payments to 69 municipalities earlier this year over financial non-compliance.


It was the moment South Africa saw a Deputy President who understands that a budget line is not just a number, it is water in a tap, it is electricity in a shack, it is a refuse truck in a township, it is a salary for a municipal worker who feeds a family, and when you withhold that money, you do not punish the corrupt official, you punish the poor.


The issue was raised by EFF leader Julius Malema, who wanted clarity on whether Mashatile had engaged Treasury over the decision and what interventions his office would pursue to prevent further service delivery failures, and EFF MP Hlengiwe Mkhaliphi, who took over the supplementary question, warned that 16 of the 69 municipalities had no cash available, raising serious concerns about their ability to provide services and pay employees.


MK Party MP Dr John Hlophe pressed further, demanding to know what consequences municipal managers and employees could face for financial misconduct, including disciplinary action, salary freezes and criminal sanctions, and what rapid-response interventions Mashatile’s office was leading to ensure those responsible were held accountable rather than having communities bear the consequences.


ACDP MP Steven Swart, putting a supplementary question on behalf of MP Kenneth Meshoe, asked whether Treasury could impose similar sanctions on non-compliant municipalities in future, pointing out that the withholding had prompted several municipalities to address outstanding compliance requirements.


Mashatile answered like a leader, not like a bureaucrat. He explained that Treasury had announced in July that it was temporarily withholding equitable-share transfers to 69 municipalities across all nine provinces after identifying persistent and serious non-compliance with the Municipal Finance Management Act and its regulations, that about R13.5 billion was initially withheld from the R110 billion allocated to municipalities for the financial year, and that by the end of July approximately R7.1 billion remained outstanding for 49 municipalities.


He said the withholding had been limited to the July tranche and that Cabinet had agreed to conditionally release the allocations to the affected municipalities, that all affected municipalities had received their July allocations and that subsequent tranches would also be paid, and that Treasury subsequently announced that the remaining funds would be released to protect service delivery, while making clear that the release did not mean the affected municipalities had met all compliance requirements.


But his strongest message was not about what happened, it was about what will never happen again. “I think we’re quite sensitive ourselves that we should not affect service delivery, particularly to poor communities,” Mashatile told Parliament, and those words mattered, because they drew a clear line.


He said National Treasury and the Department of Co-operative Governance and Traditional Affairs are considering alternative measures to hold municipal officials accountable without putting basic services at risk, that Treasury and CoGTA were working together to ensure municipalities complied with financial legislation and that officials responsible for failures were held accountable, and that the Finance and CoGTA ministers, together with their departments, were considering alternative measures to deal with municipal officials. When Hlophe demanded accountability, Mashatile did not dodge. “I agree fully with you that those other measures should be the ones that are considered,” he said, adding that disciplinary and other accountability measures should be considered instead of withholding money intended for communities, and that a report would be issued outlining how the interventions would be implemented.


Mashatile acknowledged that the intervention had prompted municipalities to comply, but he said government wanted to avoid repeating it, explaining that equitable-share allocations were different from conditional grants and that national government needed to be careful about how it handled the funding, because Treasury and CoGTA would instead develop other measures to enforce compliance while protecting service delivery.


That is leadership. That is understanding that you can be tough on corruption without being cruel to the poor. That is understanding that the mother in Limpopo who needs free basic water did not steal the money, the pensioner in the Eastern Cape who needs free basic electricity did not break the MFMA, the child in Gauteng who needs a clean street did not fail to submit financial statements, and they must never pay for the sins of officials.


And Mashatile did not come to Parliament with only words, he came with money for the people. He told MPs that Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana had announced an additional R21.8 billion for the local government equitable share in the Medium-Term Budget Policy Statement, funding intended to cover higher bulk costs associated with providing free basic water, sanitation, electricity and refuse removal, and he said Treasury and CoGTA had agreed to strengthen their co-operation to improve municipal governance, financial management and accountability.


He said the responsibility now rests with newly elected municipal leadership to establish effective financial controls and ensure compliance with the MFMA, and that government would continue supporting the two departments’ efforts to ensure that financial controls were implemented while protecting the delivery of services to communities.


This is what South Africans want to hear from their Deputy President, a leader who will stand in Parliament and say the poor come first, a leader who will protect service delivery while still demanding accountability, a leader who will punish officials, not the people. Mashatile showed that leadership on Thursday, calm, clear, compassionate, and firm, and The Azanian salutes him for it.


Comments


bottom of page