MALEMA vs ZILLE — R1 MILLION WAR: SEE YOU IN COURT

By Mpho Dube, Editor-in-Chief
The Azanian | Truth. Fearless. Unfiltered.
AZANIAFROCOMEDIA – The Catalyst of Impact
EFF leader Julius Malema is threatening a R1 million defamation lawsuit against DA Johannesburg mayoral candidate Helen Zille.
And Zille's answer, was short, cold, and brutal: No. See you in court.
The war started on Sunday, 8 November. Zille alleged on air that former Johannesburg mayor Herman Mashaba had operated as "the EFF mayor" to stay in power during his 2016 to 2019 term.
She alleged, according to IOL's report, that Mashaba allowed Malema to dictate major municipal decisions, to capture City Power, to influence a municipal fleet tender, and to instruct the appointment of Shadrack Sibiya as head of the city's anti-corruption unit.
Malema says those claims are baseless, malicious, and presented as fact to inflict political damage. His lawyers, England Slabbert Attorneys, sent a formal letter of demand on 9 November. They demanded a full retraction, a public apology, and a written undertaking not to repeat the remarks by close of business on 11 November.
Zille refused to retract or apologise. Her Cape Town-based lawyers, Minde Schapiro & Smith Inc., responded: "We have received your letter dated 9th November 2026. The answer to all your client's demands is: No. See you in court."
That one line turned a TV interview into a legal war. Now the fight is not only about what was said. It is about where it will be heard. Malema shared Zille's Notice of Opposition on X on Monday, showing the case listed in the Western Cape High Court in Cape Town, with Malema as First Applicant, the EFF as Second Applicant, and Zille as Respondent.
Malema is furious about that. He wrote: "We are suing her in Johannesburg, but she insists that the case be heard in Cape Town. What does she know about that court that gives her such confidence? She made these nonsensical remarks here in Johannesburg about Johannesburg, and she is a mayoral candidate here. Yet she wants to run to the Cape Town High Court. One day, the truth will come out. We will fight this case where the alleged conduct took place."
His argument, as reported, is simple: the alleged remarks were made in Johannesburg, about Johannesburg, and concern Johannesburg's governance, so the matter belongs in Johannesburg.
But zoom out, and this case becomes bigger than venue. It becomes about Malema himself, and the irony that IOL's Saturday Star pointed out.
Every citizen has the constitutional right to defend his name. But Malema, the man who built a political brand on unfiltered, aggressive rhetoric, is now running to the courts over political mud-slinging.
IOL documented a decade-long history of alleged insults and attacks. In 2010, while ANC Youth League president, Malema expelled BBC journalist Jonah Fisher from a press briefing at Luthuli House, allegedly calling him a "bloody agent", a "bastard", and a "small boy".
In 2018, he allegedly urged supporters to "cut the head" of enemies in the media and insulted reporters including Adriaan Basson, Pauli van Wyk, Ranjeni Munusamy, Barry Bateman and Max du Preez. SANEF took Malema and the EFF to the Equality Court, which dismissed the application in October 2019.
In 2019, the EFF and Malema published a statement accusing former Finance Minister Trevor Manuel of corruption and nepotism in the appointment of Edward Kieswetter as SARS Commissioner. Manuel sued for defamation, and the Supreme Court of Appeal upheld the High Court's ruling that the claims were unlawful and defamatory.
In 2021, during JSC interviews, Malema aggressively questioned Judge Elias Matojane over his ruling that ordered the EFF to pay R500,000 in damages to Manuel. Parliament's Joint Committee on Ethics later found Malema guilty of breaching the code of conduct, and after his High Court challenge was dismissed, Malema complied with a directive and issued a formal apology to the JSC and Judge Matojane in September 2026, according to IOL.
Law expert Vuyo Manisi told IOL that both Malema and the EFF could be held accountable for damages should victims approach the court. "The court can award financial damages or force a public retraction and apology or both," he said.
That is the tension at the heart of this R1 million war. Malema says: my name was damaged, I want justice. Zille says: I will not retract, prove it in court. The court will now decide if this time is different.
For Johannesburg, this is not just gossip. Zille is running to be mayor. Malema is fighting to keep the EFF relevant after the EFF took only 6.22% nationally in LGE2026. This court case is also an election campaign, fought with lawyers instead of loudhailers. Who blinks first? Neither side looks ready to blink.




Comments