ZUMA MAY NOT ENJOY HIS PENSION — THE STATE WANTS ITS R28.9 MILLION BACK
By Mpho Dube, Editor-in-Chief
The Azanian | Truth. Fearless. Unfiltered.
AZANIAFROCOMEDIA – The Catalyst of Impact

By Mpho Dube, Editor-in-Chief
The Azanian | Truth. Fearless. Unfiltered.
AZANIAFROCOMEDIA – The Catalyst of Impact
Former President Jacob Zuma might not enjoy his pension.
That is the brutal reality tonight. After years of legal battles, after court after court, after appeal after appeal, the Constitutional Court has slammed the door. Last week it dismissed his application for leave to appeal. It said its jurisdiction is not engaged on the merits.
It dismissed the application with costs. And with that one ruling, the bill came due: R28 960 774.34 — nearly R29 million of taxpayers' money that courts have ruled was unlawfully spent on Zuma's personal legal defence in his corruption cases.
Now Zuma is pleading with the Presidency: do not attach my pension. The JG Zuma Foundation says Zuma will ask the Presidency and the Department of Justice to exempt him from repaying the money. He wants the Presidency and the officials who took the decision to pay his legal fees to be held liable instead.
He wants a written undertaking that the state will pursue no execution — including attachment of his pension — until his new claim is decided.
This is no longer just about legal fees. This is about a former president fighting to keep his retirement.
The story goes back to 2006. Under then-President Thabo Mbeki, the Presidency decided to provide legal representation to Zuma at state expense, in accordance with Section 3(1) of the State Attorney Act.
The decision was based on advice from the then Chief State Law Advisor, the Director-General in the Department of Justice, the Minister of Justice, and the State Attorney, who all recommended it. Zuma signed undertakings on 22 August 2006 and 26 September 2008 to refund the costs if his defence was unsuccessful. The Presidency later admitted it could not locate a written agreement, but it had copies of those undertakings.
Then the DA challenged it. The High Court in Pretoria declared the Presidency's decision invalid and set it aside in December 2018. It ordered the State Attorney to take all necessary steps, including civil proceedings, to recover the money. The Supreme Court of Appeal refused leave to appeal. Now the Constitutional Court has done the same.
But Zuma's camp is not surrendering. Foundation spokesperson Mzwanele Manyi says the courts found the state's decision unlawful, but made no finding that Zuma was responsible for that decision. His argument is sharp: "Zuma did not interpret the State Attorney Act, authorise the expenditure or approve the payments. He accepted an undertaking made by the state. The court found the State's decision unlawful. It made no finding that President Zuma was responsible for that decision."
Manyi says the appeal raised a direct question under Section 172(1)(b) of the Constitution: Is it just and equitable to order a person to repay the full amount personally when the state took the unlawful decision? He says that question goes to the limits of the courts' remedial power.
It decides where accountability for unlawful public spending must fall, and what protection is owed to people who rely on the state's own undertakings. He decried the fact that the apex court dismissed the application without explaining why that question was not constitutional or not of public importance.
"Where the state makes the unlawful decision, the state must answer for the consequences of its own error. The actual perpetrator must assume full accountability," Manyi said.
Subject to legal advice, the Foundation will advise Zuma to serve notice of a claim for indemnification on the Presidency, the Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development, and the State Attorney, under Section 3 of the Institution of Legal Proceedings against Certain Organs of State Act.
The claim would cover any amount Zuma is compelled to pay. He will also be advised to call on the Director-General in the Presidency and National Treasury to act under the Public Finance Management Act and establish which officials authorised the expenditure and whether any personal liability arises.
This is the new battlefield. Zuma says: do not punish me for the state's mistake. The state says: you signed, you lost, you must pay. And in the middle stands the pension. The pension of a former president.
The pension of a man who once led the country, who now leads the MK Party, who still commands millions of supporters. If the state attaches it, it will be a moment South Africa has never seen before — a former president stripped of his retirement to pay back the state.
If the Presidency agrees not to attach it, it will be seen as protection. If it refuses, it will be seen as punishment. Either way, the country is watching.
For Zuma's supporters, this is persecution. For his critics, this is accountability finally arriving. For the ordinary South African who pays tax, who struggles to pay school fees, who watches R28.9 million and thinks of clinics, houses, water pipes — this is a simple question: who pays when the state gets it wrong?
The Concourt has spoken. The bill stands. The pension hangs in the balance.
And Jacob Zuma, the man who once said he would rather die than go to jail, is now fighting a different battle — not for freedom, but for his pension.
#TheAzanian #Zuma #JacobZuma #Concourt #Pension #R28Million #MKP #Manyi #Accountability #SouthAfrica




Comments